I assumed that Gboard spell checker contacted servers constantly and have it switched off for whatever good that does. I recently tried enabling it to play with other options and noticed that it works when my phone is entirely offline.
Does anyone know if it works locally or does it just send a bunch of data out once I give it internet access again?
Bonus question: Does anyone know of a privacy respecting spell checker for android? It looks like Florisboard can work with Hunspell through Nuspell but not on Android. Is that right?
You must log in or register to comment.
when using closed-source software, always assume it’s phoning home any chance it gets.
just so i understand that right, do you want your keyboard to spell check words as you type? if yes, i use openboard.
Interesting, it doesn’t “spell check”, but it does suggest words from its own dictionary for predictive text. Maybe I don’t need the checking if I can just look at predicted spellings. Thanks for the thought.
It does, don’t remember the details but at one point I let a packet capture tool on my phone run for a few days and checked which apps phoned home. Gboard was one of them. You’d besurprisesd at the amount of network traffic for most apps between 2-4 am.
Just remove its network permissions, and it works fine (without the phoning home part) AFAIK other spell checkers / autocomplete aren’t quite there yet
Thanks! Good to know
You can disable network access. Only thing that breaks is the GIF selector, among anything else that needs access to the internet. That’s what I do.
Yeah I have to admit I am using gboard. Although, I do have the network turned off for the application, so functionalities like built in gif search and google translate don’t work. If you don’t find a keyboard you like and want to try out gboard this would be the most private way. I mean I feel like you shouldn’t allow network to any keyboard app even if it’s audited and open source, it really has no reason to phone home.
Definitely agree
deleted by creator
The spellchecker by default does (as part of some initiative regarding improving spellcheck or whatever). There is a setting to disable it and another setting to disable telemetry. Disabling both of these effectively makes the keyboard offline apart from things like Stickers and Emojikitchen.
You can also block internet access to GBoard and it’ll work just fine.
If you don’t hard-depend on GBoard, you may wanna look into Florisboard and Helium314’s OpenBoard Fork
The spell checker uses a local dictionary. There are other things that it phones home for. IIRC, voice to text is one of them.
AnySoftKeyboard comes with a spell checker with customizable aggressiveness and dictionary.
Thanks! It does work for predictive text and correcting while typing, but doesn’t check for misspellings in typed text. Probably good enough
