I was reading this article from 1970 and he’s obviously a complicated dude: https://archive.is/POtvB
The lyrics are a little haunting and I’ve never heard it before.
“It’s really just revolutionary. I think its concept is revolutionary, and I hope it’s for workers and not for tarts and fags.”
—John Lennon
I forget just how much of a bigot and gay basher Lennon was.
Not to mention self confessed domestic abuser, and general asshole…
I’m surprised The Onion doesn’t have a headline “Man surprised that someone from Liverpool was a domestic abuser” 😂
I heard the argument the other day telling me to separate art from the artist.
My singular response was “yeah, and I like Trapped In The Closet too, but R Kelly pissed on a 13 year old girl he later married. I can’t listen to any of his music and not have that in the back of my mind. If you can stomach the song while thinking about that, the song must be pretty good or the travesty not that bad that you can push it out”
Loved Eric Clapton, read what he said about Hendrix and his own family and then the vaccine stuff in recent years resurfaced it. No more Clapton
I mean yeah, Chuck Berry used to fart on women’s faces while they were tossing his salad without consent as well, and that’s pretty fucked up. But reading the descriptions of the videos of R Kelly pissing on minors faces was just way way fucked up. Wouldn’t be able to listen to any song without thinking of all the fucked up things he’s done to other people.
Yeah there are definitely levels. Louis C.K. makes me feel weird, I think he’s funny and I think what he did was wrong but not on the level of R. Kelly or actual sexual criminals. Then the R Kelly stuff happens and it makes you re-evaluate the entire Leaderboard of ‘fucked up celebrity shit’.
Your judgement is suspect cuz u think ck is funny.
Dude CK is a legend. One of the greatest NY comics ever.
Definitely. I don’t really want to know what he did, because I want to enjoy his work. Whatever he did is nothing I can do anything about, so…
I always took it as more of a “I enjoy the art, don’t know what’s going on in the artist’s life” kinda of deal. There’s plenty of people who don’t want to hear a thing about any artist’s personal life or opinion. And it’s not fair to condemn someone that’s enjoying some art because they don’t care to keep up with the joneses.
That’s ruined the song for me
Easy to throw stones in 2023. That seems horrid now, of course, but homosexuality was literally criminalized in the UK in the 60s - the same time period where they had a gay manager. Look into the sexual tension/love affair between Epstein (Brian, not Jeffrey) and Lennon. Dude was genuinely progressive for the times (over half a fucking century ago, y’all) and to shape that as bigotry is borderline misinformation.
Rag on him for beating his wife, not this silly shit
Edit: here’s some actual context about this notorious “bigot”. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/john-lennon-the-beatles-song-defend-brian-esptein-sexuality/
Rag on him for both.
“Acceptable of the time” isn’t a valid excuse against bigotry. There’s a differenc between thinking something is criminal but having no moral objection to it, you know, like drugs and free love and everything else their music talks about, and thinking something is criminal and that there is a moral attachment to that act.
There were people in the 60s/70s/80s that wouldn’t write a workers rights song and say “keep it away from fags and girly men though”, because they’re not self-dillusioned assholes, John Lennon just didn’t happen to be one.
I’m not saying “oh, it was the 70s, fag meant something else” (even though that’s true - 60 years have gone by!). I’m saying that taking that comment out of context and labeling the guy as a bigot is some 2023 shit. Lennon was, by his own admission, bisexual - and it’s entirely possible that he actually hooked up with Epstein (and Elton John, later on).
I’m not defending the comment, to be clear. It’s quite nasty. But using that to label him as a homophobe/bigot is an absurd reach.
He was an asshole fwiw, and the domestic/child abuse is completely inexcusable. But for fucks sake, he was probably referring to hippies with that comment.
And honestly, it is important to view things in historical context. Being supportive of an quasi-openly gay person (and letting them manage your career!) when it was criminal takes balls, and that’s not something that should be erased because of one nasty quote.
He was ragging on someone for ‘fag dancing’ in the same interview, denied having relations with Brian, and called him a fag. Deep in the closet and denial and trying to talk shit to deflect, I can see. “Acting” like a bigot and a gay-basher,…maybe.
This is a cover of the song by the late Jerry Williams.
Wow, that’s intense and I think a better version.
I also love the Green Day cover.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.
There’s an early demo version out there that’s actually better than the album version. It’s more raw and emotional, which works very well for the song
It was on a compilation called “Accoustic John Lennon”…so amazing, i haven’t heard it in over a decade but think of it all the time … " a working class hero is something to be"… thanks for inspiring me to find a way out of that mess, John
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
https://piped.video/watch?v=D77dbv-xNfE
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.
Great song. Powerful strategic use of dropping the f-bomb, and just an emotionally powerful song overall. It didn’t dramatically change the world, but it got plenty of airplay and it made it’s point.
Lovely tune. I’d never heard it before either.
This one and Imagine are the best lyrics he’s ever written. Including everything he wrote alone and with Paul McCartney for The Beatles.
