

There is only 1 kind of bait.
There’s regular bait, deluxe bait, targetd bait, wild bait, magic bait and challenge bait.
Leveling up requires that you catch fish
You also get fishing XP by taking stuff out of crab pots, completing “fish pond” quests, harvesting fish pond produce, fishing up garbage items, reading the books “Bait and Bobber” or “Book of Stars”. Not a single one of these requires playing the minigame with the green bar, and only the “fish up garbage” thing requires owning a rod in the first place.
Food bonuses are true but they all require ingredients caught by fishing.
Gus can randomly sell dishes that boost your fishing skill, like Fish Taco or Trout Soup. The same goes for the travelling cart. You do not need to have any fishing experience to buy those. As for cooking those yourself, you can also buy fish from Krobus or the travelling cart, or find fish in garbage cans. And Linus can send you fish per mail (and sometimes maki rolls for whatever reason). You don’t need to actually use the fishing minigame for any of those.
because it requires you to still be checking the queen of sauce in mid-Summer of Year 2
The Queen of Sauce Book teaches you literally all recipes in the game. If you rush the Ginger Island questline you can get that reatively early.
Most people will have gotten too many reruns to keep checking at that stage of the game.
If you check the weather forecast each day (which I always do) you can see whether or not it’s a rerun before clicking on it. No idea why anyone would not check those then.
It took me 3.5 years to catch everything even with a guide
See other fish sources above. I regularily check all of these and usually manage to complete the community center in Winter Y1 or Spring Y2 unless I get the short end of the stick when using the remixed option and/or fail to get red cabbage seeds or enough Gold Star veggies in Spring Y1. Haven’t touched any guides until my third playthrough.
















Likely, yes. I got that game relatively late on the Nintendo Switch, and IIRC by that time it it was first released for that console, it had been availiable for 5+ years on PC already. Lots of time to listen to feedback and implement QOL improvements ;)